Inside MSNBC’s Secret Plot to Oust Joy Reid After Her Criticism Leaves Execs “Steaming”

May be an image of 2 people and text

The recent departure of Joy Reid from MSNBC has sparked considerable speculation and debate, revealing a complex web of corporate dynamics and personal ambitions. Known for her bold and often controversial commentary, Reid found herself at odds with network executives, who reportedly grew increasingly frustrated with her outspoken views. Sources close to the situation have indicated that executives felt her commentary was causing “heartburn” within the network’s Standards Department, leading to concern about the impact on MSNBC’s public image.

Background of Tensions at MSNBC


The mounting tensions surrounding Reid’s role at MSNBC reportedly began in late 2023. During this period, high-ranking network officials, including NBC News head Cesar Conde and the then-president of MSNBC, Rashida Jones, began contemplating her termination. Their strategy seemed to involve undercutting her position subtly; they offered her a one-year contract extension that included a pay cut, which many believe was a tactic to encourage her to resign voluntarily. However, Reid remained resolute, refusing to back down and continuing with “The Reid Out.”

As the new leadership took control in early 2025, including figures such as Rebecca Kutler, the pressure surrounding Reid’s position reached a breaking point. The executives were reportedly concerned about the tone of her analysis, especially in the lead-up to Donald Trump’s anticipated second presidential run. Ultimately, these pressures culminated in her dismissal, which was seen as both a strategic and decisively sweeping move aimed at steering MSNBC towards a less inflammatory reporting approach.

Reid’s Departure and Its Impact


The announcement of Reid’s firing not only caused significant turmoil within MSNBC, but it also had broader implications for the network’s culture. The news broke unceremoniously when a list of layoffs was mistakenly printed and shared, creating an uproar among staff and revealing the internal dissent concerning the management decisions. Veteran MSNBC host Rachel Maddow openly criticized the network for losing Reid and other non-white talent, highlighting the perceived disregard for diversity and representation within the organization’s strategy.

Mark Lazarus, the CEO of the newly formed SpinCo, played an instrumental role in Reid’s exit. His viewpoint is considered more conservative compared to his predecessors, aiming to reshape MSNBC’s editorial strategy to appeal to a more expansive audience, especially amid declining cable viewership. While there are no immediate plans for the network to shift dramatically to the right, it is apparent that management is keen to adopt a less politically charged narrative in their future programming.

The Future Outlook for MSNBC


As MSNBC navigates the aftermath of Reid’s departure, the network is poised for a broader transformation under new leadership. The goal appears to be a reimagining of the brand to appeal to varying demographics, especially younger audiences who increasingly consume media digitally. Rebecca Kutler expressed enthusiasm for exploring digital opportunities that can help transition MSNBC into a relevant entity in today’s rapidly changing media landscape.

In summary, the fallout from Joy Reid’s ousting signals a potential shift in how MSNBC addresses politically charged discussions. While the network’s leadership seeks to adjust its approach in the midst of changing viewer habits, the long-term implications of Reid’s departure—for both MSNBC and the political discourse it engages in—remain to be fully realized.