Season 23 of American Idol has officially come to a close, crowning gospel powerhouse Jamal Roberts as its winner—and now, all eyes are on what’s next for the long-running ABC competition series. While fans are already buzzing about Season 24’s 2026 return, the biggest question looming is whether Carrie Underwood will reclaim her seat at the judges’ table.

The country music icon and Idol Season 4 champion made her judging debut this past season, marking the first time a former winner joined the show as a permanent judge. Audiences quickly embraced Carrie’s fresh energy and emotional authenticity, particularly as she reflected on her own rise to fame from a small-town girl to a Grammy-winning superstar.

Carrie’s presence added a layer of nostalgia that longtime fans loved—and according to showrunner Megan Michaels, she also brought a welcome dose of tough love.
“[Carrie] really had to carve out her own role,” Michaels told TV Line. “She was stepping into the shoes of a former judge, but she needed to be her own person, and she definitely did that… I think she brought a little criticism and constructive feedback, which is very much needed.”

But despite the glowing reviews, Underwood’s future on the show remains unclear. Following the May 18 season finale, she told Entertainment Tonight, “I don’t know! There’s lots to contemplate.” That vagueness has only fueled speculation, especially after recent headlines surrounding behind-the-scenes drama—including a rumored rift between Underwood and winner Jamal Roberts.

Still, many fans are hopeful she’ll return, especially after her memorable moments on the show—including rewearing her original 2005 Idol finale dress in a stunning full-circle moment.

As American Idol preps for Season 24, producers have yet to confirm the judging panel. Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie are both reportedly in talks to return, but Carrie’s spot appears to be the biggest wildcard. Industry insiders suggest ABC is eager to have her back, but scheduling conflicts with her Las Vegas residency and upcoming tour may complicate negotiations.

Whether she returns to Idol or shifts her focus elsewhere, Carrie Underwood has already left a lasting impact this season. And for fans, her journey from contestant to judge has been a powerful reminder that dreams not only come true—they evolve.